References

Gomes B, Calanzani N, Curiale V, McCrone P, Higginson I. Effective and cost effectiveness of home Palliative care services for adults with advanced illness and their caregivers. Cochrane Database Syst Rev. 2013; 6 https://doi.org/10.1002/14651858.cd007760.pub2

National Institute for Health and Care Excellence. Emergency and acute medical care in over 16s: service delivery and organisation. 2018. https://www.nice.org.uk/guidance/ng94 (accessed 17 November 2020)

Phillips J, Johnston B, McIlfatrick S. Valuing palliative care nursing and extending the reach. Palliat Med. 2020; 34:(2)157-159 https://doi.org/10.1177/0269216319900083

Valuing community palliative care nursing during the pandemic

02 December 2020
Volume 25 · Issue 12

The thought of going into hospital for non-emergency interventions during the pandemic can be frightening, for fear of contracting the coronavirus. For people in the palliative care phase, hospitals may be considered to increase the risk of contracting the disease, and therefore, a reluctance to go into hospitals. While the rationale may focus on reducing risk, it can also allow health conditions to deteriorate, with possible fatal consequences. When this happens, most of the palliative care is provided in the community without much recognition or appreciation of the health professionals, such as community nurses, who make a positive impact on people's quality of life. While community palliative care nursing has a number of different models of provision, for example, standard and enhanced community-based palliative care, and delivered in different settings (care homes, nursing homes, hostels and patients' own homes), the central point is that, despite these differences, the outcome of care should address and support patients' pressing needs and the needs of those close to them (National Institute for Health and Care Excellence (NICE), 2018). Community palliative care nursing is set up to coordinate care through honest care planning, underpinned by empathy and holistic appreciation that patients not only come with complex needs, but that finding smart solutions will support and manage their overall wellbeing and quality of life. Offering such a humanistic approach to care does not only recognise the fears inherent in some patients about going into hospital, but reaffirms their safety while ensuring high-quality care for all. More should be done to support and appreciate community palliative care nursing, especially during this pandemic.

There is both clinical and economic evidence to suggest that community-based palliative care has better care outcomes compared with hospital-based palliative care, although the economic argument is less compelling:

  • Nineteen studies, including that by Gomes et al (2013), were reviewed as part of a Cochrane review (NICE, 2018), and all reported better outcomes in terms of death at home being the chosen place, satisfaction with care and enhanced quality of life and the end. This also meant prevention of unwanted hospital admissions
  • Enhanced community palliative care was reported to involve intensive home-based care, with qualified nurses working closely with managers and medical colleagues to improve patient outcomes (NICE, 2018)
  • Community-based palliative care provided more benefits than usual care (contact through telephone or out-patient follow-up or both) to those patients who preferred home as their place of care/death. It also reduced unwanted hospital admissions (NICE, 2018).
  • On the basis of economic outcomes focused on cost-effectiveness, community-based specialist palliative care had reduced overall costs, but the corresponding impact on quality of life was negligible (NICE, 2018). In terms of cost utility, NICE (2018) concluded that ‘one cost-utility found community-based specialist palliative care to dominate usual care, reducing costs and improving health outcomes’ (p 23). However, this evidence was also reported to have serious limitations, although this was not elaborated on. It can be argued that, despite these limitations, there are more benefits for patients receiving community-based palliative care than those who receive palliative care in hospital.

    As the pandemic seems to put more pressure on community palliative care nursing, it is critical that the NHS increases its support for community nurses to deliver the best possible palliative and end-of-life care. The minimum expectation is that community nurses are equipped with the basics necessary to deliver generalist palliative care. Phillips et al (2020) went further and suggested that every nurse should be trained to deliver generalist palliative care, and that this can be achieved through whole-system reform and investment to create sustainable capabilities at the generalist level. At this level, nurses are able to conduct a full assessment and identify and then devise an effective plan to manage both physical and psychological symptoms, such as mild pain and anxiety, while being aware of advanced care planning needs and when to refer to other more experienced clinicians. Undoubtedly, effective communication skills are fundamentally important in palliative care (Phillips et al, 2020), and efforts should, therefore, be directed towards upskilling community nurses so that they can confidently facilitate dialogues with patients and families about treatment options and choices about care and death.